July 19, 2008
It's horribly delicious

The third and final act of Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog is up. Joss Whedon is all about subverting genre expectations, and this is no different. You've got a supervillain who's actually pretty nice, versus a superhero who's a mean, creepy, preening jackass. When they both go after the same girl... oof. The songs are really catchy (and, as in "Once More with Feeling," actually drive the plot), it's by turns hilarious and heartwrenching, and the actors are all committed 100%. I'm a semi-hopeless Whedon fanboy, granted, but I think this might be the best thing he's ever done.
And it's on a budget! They've created an epic tale of blind ambition, betrayal, and revenge, and it's set mostly in a crappy apartment and a laundromat, with costumes no more elaborate than a t-shirt, a lab coat, and a very cleverly employed pair of welding goggles. Yeah, it's clear they spent more money than your average webshow, but not that much more. Good writing and acting: it's nature's CGI!
Not to be spoiley, but this certainly didn't end the way I thought it was going to. Which is good. (Or bad? Badgood? Bood?)
Why are you still reading this? The whole thing is only going to be up until Sunday at midnight, and then you'll have to pay to watch it. Which you should anyway, for something this great, but why wait? Go!
P.S. Hey, you're back. Okay, the reason this is actually better than "Once More with Feeling," even though that was arguably more of a achievement, is because this is self-contained. You don't need to know anything going in; it's all there. "OMwF" was amazing in that it advanced an ongoing storyline in musical form, but I'm sure it loses something if you've never seen an episode of Buffy before. So that's why that's what I think about that.
http://blowingsmokethemovie.com/cgi-bin/mt-app/mt-tb.cgi/2702
I really gotta give Whedon one thing- he can turn on a dime.
The whole thing was just funny to me. I was not vested in the characters, it was too funny for ANY pathos or any of that crap you're talking about. Until the last second, literally only one second. That's impressive: suddenly, after making a comedy that is comedic throughout, creating depth in character. That's actually impressive.
Comment by James Wiggum on July 19, 2008 3:24 PM
You can't be invested in the characters in a comedy? Which is mutually exclusive from tragedy? Well how about that.
Comment by Treach on July 19, 2008 3:31 PM
That was pretty impressive. I wish more people in Hollywood would realize that you don't necessarily need a huge budget and computer graphics everywhere to make something that's really entertaining.
Comment by Sean M. on July 19, 2008 5:48 PM
Not in characters solely comedic in character, no. None of these characters did anything except joke (to my eyes) until the last literal second.
So if you're not really asking "can't [I] be invested" in a comedy but "WAS I invested?" in this particular one, the answer was no, not in the slightest. It was captain hammer and doctor horrible. It's like being invested in a Bazooka Joe gum wrapper.
Which is why it was impressive. The whole thing was nothing, but at the end he actually did something. Hence my point.
Comment by James Wiggum on July 19, 2008 8:59 PM
None of these characters did anything except joke (to my eyes) until the last literal second.
Wrong. So very, very wrong.
Comment by Treach on July 19, 2008 9:01 PM



